Decide an appeal by an independent panel
Open the journey AEC 7 of 9
| Trigger | An appeal is lodged |
|---|---|
| Outcome | The panel decision is made by members with no part in the original decision, with reasons. |
| Sender | Appeals panel |
| Receiver | Project developer |
| Records and receipts | Appeal decision with reasons; receipt; every receipt carries a tok id |
| Permissions | Panel independent of the original decision; every actor is bound to an EDGE ID and every agent act carries its ATBAN |
| Regulation | Charcoal is a voluntary standard-setter and certification scheme seeking government recognition; statutory regulator status needs legislation. Modelled on FSMA 2000 s.138I consultation and the FCA Handbook processes; Regulators' Code 2014; Climate Change Act 2008 |
| Blueprint | — |
| Benchmarks | BM-CHARCOAL-01 |
| tok | tok-994d39599231ba03fa5cff497f7332c9 |
Steps
| 1 | Select the appeal |
| 2 | Record the panel members and independence checks |
| 3 | Record the hearing |
| 4 | Record the panel decision |
| 5 | Record the decision receipt |
Cases
| happy path | The panel decision is made by members with no part in the original decision, with reasons. |
| receiving side | the project developer sees the appeal decision and the same receipt id |
| failure path | panel member conflicted |
| failure path | hearing adjourned |
| failure path | expired EDGE ID session |
| seven widths, both themes | no overflow, no cut text, axe serious or critical = 0 |
| independent re-run | a non-builder agent reproduces the happy path from the reproduce command with the same result |